'If suffering can have a creative meaning, Hermann Haindl's life and work were formed by it.' ~ Erika Haindl
In my last post I mentioned I dislike Rachel Pollack's books about this deck. I should clarify by saying that in the past I've found them a bit frustrating, or did when I read them a few years ago upon buying my first Haindl Tarot deck. They seem as stream-of-consciousness as Haindl's paintings themselves, and that can be frustrating when you have come to a guidebook to make order of such complexity, only to find the explanations as abstract-random as the cards themselves. For me part of the problem is that each chapter starts with the Hebrew letters, runes, astrology, and/or I-Ching, and you have to skim past all this to get to the actual card images. For me this is a problem, as
I do not like adding separate systems to tarot, and for me these are all unnecessary add-ons that get in my way! I have been dipping into them for the last couple of days and can say I still find them a little rambly--and think they could be offputting indeed to dewy-eyed tarot newbies--they are useful for gleaning insights into the artist's mindset and some of the curious elements of the cards.
If you're willing to plow through the detail and continuously remind yourself that these are Rachel Pollack's personal thoughts about these cards (sometimes with input from Haindl himself, but often just her own responses), the book can help with some of the more mysterious or curious elements on the cards, particularly with the majors. The books are not essential, though. When all is said and done, as deeply personal a tarot as this is, it is still a tarot, and if you bring to it Thoth/Golden Dawn interpretations (which can differ from contemporary RWS ones), it doesn't matter if you can interpret every single 'cosmic bubble' or cryptic reference to Wagner. It doesn't matter if you know Aleph from Tau, or what a tallis is. You can still read with this deck.
And that's the important thing, because as Rachel Pollack points out in the introduction, the Haindl Tarot is not an occult deck, not in the sense of the Thoth et al. It is, as she points out, 'a sacred tarot, one which reaches back to ancient spiritual traditions and cultures...leading us to see the world as a vessel filled with spiritual power and truth' (
Haindl Tarot: Major Arcana, New Page Books, 12).